Wesley United Methodist Church started in the beginning years of heady days of growth in Warren. The congregation started its service in a Shepard School in 1961. Forty-six families were the beginning membership.

The end of the first year brought the membership up to 114. This success generated the drive to build a church. The original construction was completed in 1964. Eventually, the Wesley United Methodist Church was merged with the Roseville United Methodist Church. This frees this facility to be used by another church.